The apologists for homeopathy are upset again: this time with Professor Edzard Ernst and Simon Singh’s new book. Why? Because once more homeopathy is exposed for what it is: a placebo.
Dr Damien Downing, the Medical Director for the Alliance for Natural Health (ANH), seems particularly put out. So much so that he has released a rather silly critique. (This link seems to be down. Try here)
After some empty carping he suggests that Ernst is not a very good scientist and then goes on to wrap himself in the flag of good science, “The scientific method ‘consists of the collection of data through observation and experimentation, and the formulation and testing of hypotheses’ (Wikipedia) – not of unsubstantiated dogmatic statements. Science has no room for dogma.”
This is one point I can agree with; compared to the statements of some other protagonists it’s pretty reasonable: science should have no room for dogma. However, Downing is not averse to peddling some homeopathic propaganda.
Read the rest of this entry »
You must be logged in to post a comment.